AI Can't Dance (Resources) Texas Tech

AI Can’t Dance.

Creative Horizons: Emerging Technologies Speaker Series
School of Theatre & Dance · Talkington College of Visual & Performing Arts · Texas Tech University · November 20, 2026

Generative AI, creative thinking, and the future of arts education. Everything from the session in one place, plus reading for the semester ahead.

(I LOVE THIS POEM)

For a Student Who Used AI to Write a Paper

Joseph Fasano

Now I let it fall back

in the grasses.

I hear you. I know

this life is hard now.

I know your days are precious

on this earth.

But what are you trying

to be free of?

The living? The miraculous

task of it?

Love is for the ones who love the work.

Love is for the ones who love the work.

Sourced from poets.org, Academy of American Poets.

Open. Receptive. Human-centered.

Three postures for approaching using AI in the arts as humans.

Open.

Start from curiosity, not fear and not hype. Be willing to try the tool, and willing not to know. Open doesn’t mean uncritical. It means you look before you decide.

Try the tool before you rule it out. Then tell students when and where it belongs, and why.

Receptive.

Let things change you: critique, evidence, your students, an audience. That’s how art works. AI fakes receptivity, because it’s built to agree with you. A sparring partner pushes back.

Use AI to push back on you, never just to agree with you. Ask it what’s weak. Then decide for yourself.

Human-centered.

The person is the point. Judge every use of AI by what it does to the student, not by what it produces for them. Protect the reps that have to happen in the body.

Protect the practice. Keep a witness in the room: a teacher, a peer, an audience.

And don’t fool yourself.

The big ideas

What is dance?

If dance is a body moving in a coordinated way, the robot passes easily. Judith Lynne Hanna calls it human behavior that is “purposeful, intentionally rhythmical, and culturally patterned.” Purposeful to whom? Patterned by which culture? Every answer needs a person in it.

Practiced. Improvised. Expressed.

Real dance lives in a trained body, makes choices nobody predicted, and carries something from a lived life. Art is embodied. As Mark Johnson argues, meaning grows out of the body. We don’t think first and then move.

AI works against each part of the dance

It shortcuts the practice. It predicts instead of improvising, drifting toward the average. It flatters instead of witnessing: every student now carries a tireless yes-machine.

Depend or spar?

The same tool can put a student on two curves. Used as a substitute, capability erodes. Used as a sparring partner, capability grows. The tool doesn’t decide which curve. The posture does, and posture can be taught.

Convenience feels like learning.

Challenge is learning. Students with an answer-giving AI tutor did better in practice and worse on the exam. The ones whose tutor gave hints largely avoided the harm.

The order matters

Human skills at the base, craft in the middle (voice, body, design, stagecraft), and specific, fleeting technical skills on top. The tools will change before our students graduate. The human layer is AI-resistant and highly transferable.

Five human capabilities

Curiosity, creativity, critical thinking, communication, collaboration. Which one are your students getting best? Which one could AI quietly erode? Theatre and dance already teach all five, by design.

Where does authority live?

Aristotle’s logos, ethos, and pathos: the argument, the credibility, the feeling. Johan Roos gives the machine the argument and keeps the feeling human. Move that line and you change what you teach. Where does your teaching put it right now?

More human, not less

In a world full of synthetic everything, people are paying more to be in the room. “Made by humans” has become a selling point. Our job is to form artists who can make meaning, take a risk, hold a standard, and care about the people next to them.

Take these home

For your next faculty meeting, production meeting, or first day of class.

For your studio or rehearsal room

What happens in your studio, rehearsal room, or shop that AI can’t, or shouldn’t, replace?

  • Would your students give the same answer?
  • Have you made it clear to them?
  • Where are they already shortcutting it?

Five questions for your program

  • Who are we?
  • What is our why?
  • What do we do?
  • How do we do it?
  • Does AI interfere with any of those answers?

What’s your next step?
Stay open. Try the tool before you rule it out, and name the line for your students. Stay receptive. Use it to push back on you, never just to agree with you. Stay human-centered. Protect the practice, and keep a witness in the room. But don’t fool yourself.

Tools + policy

Practical structures for talking about AI with faculty and students, from campus guidance to the single assignment.

Texas Tech’s AI Use Levels

Updated by the Teaching, Learning, and Professional Development Center in fall 2026. Picking a level for a project is drawing the line between the AI domain and the human domain, on purpose. The guidance also notes that generative AI isn’t approved for grading at Texas Tech, and that students should never be asked to put sensitive or protected information into an outside AI tool.

LEVEL 0Independent work without generative AI

No AI may generate, solve, summarize, translate, or revise the work.

LEVEL 1Learning support and planning

Concepts, practice, brainstorming, and outlines. AI-made language or media stays out of the submission.

LEVEL 2AI-assisted collaboration

Only for the uses the assignment names. Students originate the central ideas and verify everything.

LEVEL 3AI-integrated work

AI use is expected. Judgment, verification, and documentation are graded.

Read the TTU guidance + sample syllabus statements

The REAL Framework

An ethically grounded model for the responsible use of AI in education. It asks what AI produces in us, not just what it produces. The first two questions look at the present; the last two look at who we become over time. It applies to faculty as much as to students.

Retained

What essential qualities of genuine human relationships and habits are being preserved?
Student check: Am I still doing the thinking, or has this tool begun thinking for me?

Eroded

What aspects of learning, habit, or formation are being quietly weakened?
Student check: Is this tool helping me engage more deeply, or making it easier and shallower?

Atrophied

What skills risk being lost over time through reliance on the tool?
Student check: If I keep using it this way, what will I stop being able to do?

Leveraged

How can AI strengthen learning or access without replacing human responsibility?
Student check: Is this helping me learn, or helping me avoid the work of learning?

Download the REAL Framework (PDF)

Another model: Anderson University’s AI Use Scale

Six levels instead of four, adapted from Leon Furze’s AI Assessment Scale. Same idea: put the level on the syllabus or the assignment sheet, and the guessing stops. Any use of AI must always be acknowledged.

LEVEL 0No AI use

Show independent knowledge or skill. In-class work, critique, exams.

LEVEL 1Information retrieval

Research and definitions. Verify everything.

LEVEL 2AI-assisted ideation

Brainstorm and outline. You author or execute the final work.

LEVEL 3AI-assisted editing

Refine language or media. Submit drafts alongside the AI-refined version.

LEVEL 4AI tasks, human evaluation

Generate, then critique. Your analysis is what gets graded.

LEVEL 5Full AI co-creation

AI as a creative collaborator throughout the work.

Download the AU AI Use Scale (PDF)
Assessment

The AI Assessment Scale (AIAS)

Perkins, Furze, Roe & MacVaugh

The widely adopted five-level scale behind many campus policies. Free to adapt, with a peer-reviewed update.

Ethics

Teaching AI Ethics

Leon Furze · free eBook, CC BY-NC

Bias, environment, truth, copyright, privacy, datafication, affect recognition, human labour, and power, with discussion prompts for every discipline.

Policy

Guidance for Generative AI in Education and Research

UNESCO

A global, human-centered starting point for policy, with steps for regulating and validating AI tools.

Bias

Algorithmic Justice League

Founded by Joy Buolamwini

Research, art, and advocacy on who gets seen, and missed, by AI systems. A great on-ramp for students in any studio.

Stay current

AI, Academia, and the Future

Bryan Alexander · newsletter

A futurist’s steady, readable scan of AI across higher education: policy, economics, teaching, and where it all might be heading.

For performers

Creative careers now come with new questions about the body, the voice, and the contract. And some good news about the room.

Every performer should be able to answer

  • Who owns my face?
  • My voice?
  • My movement, once it’s captured as data?
  • What exactly am I signing?

Where the union stands

In 2023, SAG-AFTRA struck for 118 days, with AI at the center. In 2025, when a studio introduced an AI “actress,” the union said plainly that she isn’t an actor. Its 2026 film and TV contract requires consent and pay for digital replicas and limits synthetic performers. Those protections cover union work. Many first jobs aren’t union jobs.

SAG-AFTRA AI resources

The appetite for live is growing

$1.91B

Broadway grosses for the 2025–26 season, a record. The Broadway League

14.6M

Broadway attendances, the highest since the pre-pandemic peak.

37M+

Theatre visits in the UK in 2025. Theatre in the UK 2026

74%

of Gen Z say in-person experiences matter more than digital ones. Eventbrite Social Study 2026

The honest part: demand isn’t the same as jobs. 36% of UK theatres expect an operating deficit this year, rising to 51% in the subsidised sector.

Books

The shelf behind the talk, plus a few for leading the change in your own program.

On AI and learning

Start here

Human Magic: Leading with Wisdom in an Age of Algorithms

Johan Roos · Routledge, 2026

The backbone of the session: the two curves, the five capabilities, Hult’s layered curriculum, and the “hybrid authority” diagram behind the authority line. “AI brings the options, but humans bring the meaning.”

Teaching

Teaching with AI: A Practical Guide to a New Era of Human Learning

José Antonio Bowen & C. Edward Watson · 2nd ed., Johns Hopkins, 2025

An essential guide for postsecondary educators on how AI is changing learning, and how teachers can adapt while protecting human thinking and integrity.

Working with AI

Co-Intelligence: Living and Working with AI

Ethan Mollick · Portfolio, 2024

Treat AI as a co-worker and co-teacher. Practical principles for how it changes education and work, from one of the clearest voices in the field.

Another view

Brave New Words: How AI Will Revolutionize Education (and Why That’s a Good Thing)

Salman Khan · Viking, 2024

The Khan Academy founder’s case for AI tutoring, including Khanmigo. Worth reading alongside the research on answer-giving tutors.

On dance, the body, and making

Dance

To Dance Is Human: A Theory of Nonverbal Communication

Judith Lynne Hanna · rev. ed., 1987 (first published by the University of Texas Press, 1979)

An anthropologist’s definition of dance as purposeful, rhythmical, and culturally patterned. The question the robots can’t answer.

The body

The Meaning of the Body: Aesthetics of Human Understanding

Mark Johnson · University of Chicago Press, 2007

The philosophical case that meaning grows out of bodily experience. A strong backbone for anyone who teaches through the body.

Practice

The Creative Habit

Twyla Tharp · Simon & Schuster, 2003

A choreographer on discipline, preparation, and showing up every day. The practice AI offers to skip.

Imagination

Lifting the Veil: Imagination and the Kingdom of God

Malcolm Guite · Canterbury Press, 2021

A poet-priest’s defense of imagination as a way of knowing truth, not just decorating it. “Everything begins bodily.”

On leading

Leadership

Start with Why

Simon Sinek · 2009

The engine behind the five program questions. If AI can do the what and the how, the why is what’s left.

Leadership

When Everyone Leads: How the Toughest Challenges Get Seen and Solved

Ed O’Malley & Julia Fabris McBride · 2023

Leadership as an activity anyone can exercise, not a position. Built for adaptive problems like this one, where no one has the answer yet.

Psychological safety

The Fearless Organization

Amy C. Edmondson · Wiley, 2019

The research on why people take risks, speak up, and learn, and how to hold high standards and high safety at once. Every rehearsal room runs on it.

Hospitality + care

Unreasonable Hospitality

Will Guidara · 2022

How the most human details create loyalty. Read it thinking about the student experience, and the audience’s.

On students, care, and standards

Students now

The Anxious Generation

Jonathan Haidt · 2024

How phone-based childhood rewired the students arriving in our studios and rehearsal halls.

Students now

The Coddling of the American Mind

Greg Lukianoff & Jonathan Haidt · 2018

On fragility, safety, and why struggle matters, an argument for keeping productive friction in the work.

Standards

Boundaries

Henry Cloud & John Townsend · 1992

Care and limits belong together. Useful for the “not yet, try it again” conversations a yes-machine never has.

Teaching

Teaching to Transgress

bell hooks · Routledge, 1994

Engaged pedagogy and the classroom as “the most radical space of possibility.” For us, that’s the studio, the rehearsal hall, and the shop.

On art, seeing, and story

Seeing

Understanding a Photograph

John Berger · ed. Geoff Dyer · Aperture, 2013

The camera never made anyone a photographer. Someone still has to learn to see.

The artist’s role

Collected Essays

James Baldwin · Library of America

Includes “The Creative Process” (1962), on the artist’s job to make the world “a more human dwelling place.”

Fiction

The Left Hand of Darkness

Ursula K. Le Guin · 1969

Uncertainty isn’t a problem to solve before we start. It’s the condition we work in. Every rehearsal begins there.

Mentorship

The Hero with a Thousand Faces

Joseph Campbell · 1949

Every hero needs a mentor, and the mentor never fights the dragon for them.

Research

The studies behind the claims, plus a few more worth bringing to your next curriculum conversation.

Learning

Generative AI without guardrails can harm learning

Bastani et al. · PNAS, 2025

Students with an answer-giving AI tutor did better in practice, worse on the exam, and believed they’d learned just as much. A tutor that gave hints did no harm.

Sycophancy

Sycophantic AI decreases prosocial intentions and promotes dependence

Cheng et al. · Science, 2026

AI that agrees with us makes us less willing to repair conflict, and more likely to come back for more. The opposite of receptive.

Critical thinking

The impact of generative AI on critical thinking

Lee et al. · Microsoft Research, CHI 2025

The more people trusted AI, the less critical thinking they reported doing. Confidence in your own skill pushed the other way.

Jobs

Canaries in the coal mine?

Brynjolfsson, Chandar & Chen · Stanford Digital Economy Lab, 2025

Early-career workers in AI-exposed jobs are seeing the first employment declines. Entry-level work is the apprenticeship, and it’s shrinking.

Mentorship

Great jobs, great lives

Gallup–Purdue Index · 2014

A professor who made them excited to learn, one who cared about them as a person, and a mentor. Only 14% of graduates had all three, and they were more than twice as likely to be engaged at work.

Live audiences

Social Study 2026: Reset to Real

Eventbrite · 2026

Gen Z and Millennials want live experiences that feel unscripted, participatory, and real. Useful data for anyone recruiting performers, or audiences.

Uncanny

The uncanny valley

Masahiro Mori · 1970 · English translation, IEEE Spectrum

The original short essay on why the almost-human unsettles us. Pairs well with any dancing-robot video.

Watch + read

  • A tale of two holiday ads · The Verge, 2025 · How Apple made “A Critter Carol” with handmade puppets and real puppeteers, the same season Coca-Cola went with generative AI. Read
  • Unitree robots dancing · The clip from the session. Impressive, precise, and worth asking: is it dancing? Watch
  • Johan Roos, “Essential human capabilities in the age of AI” · Luxembourg School of Business · The author of Human Magic on the capabilities behind the session. Watch
  • Jacob Collier, “The wiggly wonder of music” · TED, 2026 · Why the wiggle, the human imperfection, is the point. Watch
  • Malcolm Guite in conversation · Comment, 2021 · A poet-priest on imagination, embodiment, and why making matters. Read
  • Joy Buolamwini, “How I’m fighting bias in algorithms” · TED, 2016 · Who codes matters. Watch
  • Simon Sinek, “How great leaders inspire action” · TEDx, 2009 · The golden circle behind “What is our why?” Watch
  • Amy Edmondson, “How to turn a group of strangers into a team” · TED, 2017 · Psychological safety in practice. Watch
  • Richard Feynman, “Cargo Cult Science” · Caltech commencement, 1974 · “You must not fool yourself.” Read
  • Toni Morrison, “No Place for Self-Pity, No Room for Fear” · The Nation, 2015 · “This is precisely the time when artists go to work.” Read
  • Robert Frost, “The Figure a Poem Makes” · 1939 · The preface to his Collected Poems: “It begins in delight and ends in wisdom.”
  • Quote Investigator on Maya Angelou’s “You can’t use up creativity” · Tracing the line to a 1982 interview. Read

Voices from the session

“The only thing that makes life possible is permanent, intolerable uncertainty: not knowing what comes next.”

Ursula K. Le Guin The Left Hand of Darkness, 1969

“Our bodies are the very condition of our meaning making and creativity.”

Mark Johnson The Meaning of the Body, 2007

“Everything begins bodily.”

Malcolm Guite Comment, 2021

“You can’t use up creativity. The more you use, the more you have.”

Maya Angelou Bell Telephone Magazine, 1982

“No tears in the writer, no tears in the reader. No surprise for the writer, no surprise for the reader.”

Robert Frost “The Figure a Poem Makes,” 1939

“The first principle is that you must not fool yourself—and you are the easiest person to fool.”

Richard Feynman “Cargo Cult Science,” 1974

“Who codes matters, how we code matters, and why we code matters.”

Joy Buolamwini TED, 2016

“The precise role of the artist, then, is to illuminate that darkness, blaze roads through that vast forest, so that we will not, in all our doing, lose sight of its purpose, which is, after all, to make the world a more human dwelling place.”

James Baldwin “The Creative Process,” 1962

“The classroom remains the most radical space of possibility in the academy.”

bell hooks Teaching to Transgress, 1994

“This is precisely the time when artists go to work. There is no time for despair, no place for self-pity, no need for silence, no room for fear.”

Toni Morrison The Nation, 2015

AI can’t dance.
Our students can.

Thank you, Texas Tech School of Theatre & Dance.

Jer Nelsen
Interim Dean, South Carolina School of the Arts
Anderson University

Get in touch